How to Test Product Prices on Shopify Using Real Conversion Data

Pricing decisions can quietly make or break your Shopify store. Many merchants lower prices, hoping for more sales, only to find revenue flat, or worse, down. The real problem isn’t the price itself, but the lack of data behind the decision. Price testing changes that. By testing different price points on real Shopify traffic, you can see how customers actually respond, which is measured in conversions, revenue per visitor, and profit, not guesses.

Today, let’s go through how to test product prices on Shopify using real conversion data, what to measure, how long to test, and how to choose a winning price with confidence.

Selling on Shopify for only $1

Start with 3-day free trial and next 3 months for just $1/month.

Start $1 Shopify

What Is Price Testing on Shopify

Price testing on Shopify is the process of showing different price points for the same product to separate groups of visitors and measuring how each version performs using real conversion data.

Instead of relying on intuition or competitor benchmarks, merchants run controlled pricing experiments to understand how price directly affects buying behavior.

In a standard setup:

• One group of visitors sees price A

• Another group sees price B

• Both variants run at the same time under identical conditions

This ensures performance differences come from price alone, not traffic quality or timing.

According to Shopify, pricing tests allow merchants to compare price variants and observe how different price points impact conversion rates and profits, helping identify optimal pricing structures based on actual customer behavior rather than assumptions.

The primary goal of price testing is not just higher conversions. It’s to identify the price that drives the highest revenue per visitor, a more reliable growth metric than conversion rate alone.

Price testing is especially powerful because pricing influences:

• Perceived product value

• Trust and quality signals

• Willingness to complete a purchase

Even small price changes can outperform layout or copy optimizations when measured correctly. By using structured experiments, Shopify merchants can move from guesswork to evidence-backed pricing decisions.

Learn more: A/B Testing on Shopify: How to Turn Your Tests Into Real Conversion Gains

Pricing Testing vs Discount Testing: What’s the Difference

Pricing testing and discount testing are often treated as the same thing, but they solve very different business problems. Understanding the difference is critical if you want to optimize revenue, not just short-term conversions.

Pricing testing focuses on testing different base price points for a product.

For example, showing one group of visitors a product priced at $29 and another group the same product priced at $33. The goal is to understand how price affects conversion rate, average order value, and revenue per visitor. From which the store owner can ultimately identify the price customers are truly willing to pay.

Discount testing, on the other hand, tests promotional mechanics such as percentage discounts, fixed-amount offers, or limited-time deals.

While discounts often increase conversions quickly, they can distort customer behavior. Shoppers may delay purchases, anchor on discounted prices, or associate your brand with constant promotions, which can hurt long-term margins and brand perception.

Here’s the key difference in outcomes:

• Pricing tests help you optimize revenue and profitability by validating price elasticity.

• Discount tests primarily optimize short-term conversion spikes, often at the cost of margin.

• Pricing experiments inform long-term pricing strategy.

• Discount experiments inform promotion tactics, not true product value.

For Shopify merchants focused on sustainable growth, pricing testing should come before discount testing. Once the right base price is validated through experiments, discounts can be layered strategically without eroding perceived value or revenue.

Why Shopify Merchants Should Actually Test Prices

Pricing is one of the few levers that directly affects every single transaction in your Shopify store. Yet it’s also one of the most commonly guessed decisions. Price testing exists to remove that guesswork, and replace it with measurable revenue impact.

E-commerce Pricing directly Impacts Revenue

When pricing is optimized, small changes can produce outsized results. This is why experienced growth teams evaluate price performance using revenue per visitor (RPV), not conversion rate alone.

Consider a simple example:

• Version A: $30 price, 3% conversion rate

• Version B: $33 price, 2.9% conversion rate

Even with a slightly lower conversion rate, Version B can generate more total revenue per visitor. This is why price testing often outperforms design or copy experiments in terms of business impact.

Gut-based Pricing Decisions don’t Scale

Many Shopify merchants still rely on:

• Competitor pricing

• “Round number” instincts

• Temporary sales performance

The problem is that buyer behavior is contextual. The same price can perform very differently depending on:

• Traffic source

• Product positioning

• Audience intent

• Perceived value

Shopify Analytics can show sales trends, but it doesn’t reveal how sensitive customers are to price changes or where the optimal price actually sits.

Pricing Test is a Low-risk Optimization

Well-structured pricing experiments allow you to:

• Quantify price elasticity (how demand changes as price changes)

• Measure real buyer behavior instead of assumptions

• Compare price variants under the same traffic conditions

• Make pricing decisions with clear revenue trade-offs

Unlike permanent price changes, price testing runs on a limited traffic split, has a clear start & end point, and produces statistically measurable outcomes.

That makes price testing one of the lowest-risk, highest-ROI experiments Shopify merchants can run, especially when growth decisions need to be justified with data.

A Practical Framework for Running Price Tests on Shopify

This framework is designed for Shopify merchants who want to test pricing decisions using real conversion data, not assumptions. Each step builds on the previous one, so you can isolate price impact without introducing noise into your results.

Step 1: Start With a Clear Pricing Hypothesis

Every pricing experiment should begin with a specific, testable hypothesis. Without it, results are easy to misread or over-optimize.

A strong pricing hypothesis includes:

• A price change (from X to Y)

• A target metric (conversion rate, revenue per visitor, or AOV)

• A business outcome

Example hypothesis: “If we price this product at $34 instead of $29, revenue per visitor will increase without significantly reducing conversion rate.”

Avoid vague goals like “see what happens” or “optimize pricing.” Price tests work best when they answer one focused question at a time.

Step 2: Choose Metrics That Actually Reflect Revenue Impact

Price testing is not about maximizing conversion rate alone. A lower price may convert better but still lose money.

Use this metric hierarchy when evaluating pricing experiments:

• Primary metric: Revenue per visitor (RPV) is the most reliable indicator of pricing performance

• Secondary metrics:

  • Conversion rate (CR)

  • Average order value (AOV)

• Supporting signals: Engagement, bounce rate, repeat purchases

In pricing experiments, RPV matters more than CR because it captures both price and conversion effects in one metric.

This approach aligns with how Shopify frames pricing tests: as a way to measure how different price points affect both conversion rates and profits, not just clicks or orders.

Step 3: Decide Sample Size and Test Duration

Pricing tests need enough data to be trustworthy. Ending too early is one of the most common mistakes.

As a general rule, you should run price tests for at least 2–4 business cycles. For most Shopify stores, that means 14–28 days, depending on traffic volume

This helps:

• Smooth out weekday vs weekend behavior

• Avoid short-term campaign spikes

• Reach statistical confidence

If traffic is low, prioritize fewer variants and longer duration rather than splitting traffic too thin.

Step 4: Set Up a Price Test on Shopify

Shopify does not support native price A/B testing out of the box. Most pricing experiments require third-party apps like GemX to split traffic and track variant performance.

Learn more: How to Set Up Your First Experiment in GemX

Common setup flow:

1. Create two price variants for the same product

2. Split incoming traffic evenly between variants

3. Track key metrics (RPV, CR, AOV)

4. Monitor results until statistical confidence is reached

5. Apply the winning price permanently

For Shopify Plus stores, limited checkout-level experiments may be possible, but most merchants rely on apps for flexibility and clean measurement.

Price Testing Ideas You Can Try on Shopify

If you’re new to pricing experiments, don’t overcomplicate things. The most effective price tests on Shopify usually focus on simple, high-impact variations that answer one clear question at a time.

Below are proven pricing test formats you can run using real store traffic.

1. Base Price vs Slightly Higher Price

This is the simplest and most common product price A/B test.

Example:

• Variant A: $29.99

• Variant B: $31.99

What this test reveals:

• Price sensitivity of your audience

• Whether a small increase impacts conversion rate

• How price changes affect revenue per visitor

This type of test works especially well for:

• High-traffic products

• Products with strong perceived value

• Stores unsure if they’re underpricing

2. Single Product Price vs Bundle Price

Instead of changing the base price, you test value framing.

Example:

• Variant A: 1 item for $39

• Variant B: 2 items for $69

What this test reveals:

• Willingness to pay for perceived savings

• Impact on average order value (AOV)

• Whether bundles outperform single-item pricing

This pricing experiment is ideal for:

• Consumable or repeat-use products

• Brands looking to increase AOV without discounts

3. Product Price Combined with Shipping Cost Changes

Shipping costs often act as a hidden price signal. Testing price without considering shipping can lead to misleading conclusions.

Example:

• Variant A: Product $30 + $5 shipping

• Variant B: Product $34 + free shipping

What this test reveals:

• Whether customers respond more to total cost or price structure

• Impact on checkout completion rate

• Changes in perceived transparency and trust

This test is especially useful for Shopify stores with high cart abandonment.

4. Time-Limited Price vs Permanent Price

This test compares urgency-driven pricing with stable pricing.

Example:

• Variant A: $29 (limited-time price)

• Variant B: $32 (permanent price)

What this test reveals:

• Short-term conversion lift vs long-term revenue stability

• Whether urgency actually improves revenue per visitor

• Risk of training customers to wait for lower prices

Run this carefully and monitor results beyond just conversion rate.

Pro tip: For valid pricing experiments:
1. Change only the price, not copy, layout, or images
2. Keep traffic sources consistent
3. Run tests long enough to reach confidence
Multiple simultaneous changes make results impossible to interpret correctly.

Real Price Testing Examples From Shopify Stores

Seeing pricing experiments in action makes it easier to understand how price testing works, and why data often beats intuition.

Below are two realistic examples based on common Shopify store scenarios.

Example 1: Testing a Higher Price on a Best-Selling Product

Before the test: A Shopify store sells a hero product at $29.99. The product converts well, but margins are tight and the team suspects the product may be underpriced.

Key baseline metrics:

• Conversion rate: 3.1%

• Revenue per visitor (RPV): $0.93

The test setup

• Variant A: $29.99

• Variant B: $32.50

• Traffic split: 50/50

• Duration: 21 days

• Primary metric: Revenue per visitor

After the test

• Variant B conversion rate dropped slightly to 2.9%

• However, RPV increased by 7.4%

• Total revenue from Variant B outperformed Variant A despite fewer orders

Decision: The store rolled out the higher price permanently. Even with a minor conversion drop, the price increase delivered higher overall revenue.

Find the Price That Maximizes Revenue

GemX empowers you to test product prices with real conversion data, not gut feeling.

Start Free Trial

Example 2: Single Item vs Bundle Pricing

Before the test: A consumable product sells for $39 per unit, with low average order value.

Baseline:

• AOV: $41

• RPV: $1.12

The test setup

• Variant A: 1 unit for $39

• Variant B: 2 units for $69

• Same product page, same traffic sources

• Focus metrics: AOV and RPV

After the test

• Bundle variant converted slightly less

• AOV increased by over 50%

• RPV increased by 18%

Decision: The store kept both options but highlighted the bundle as the default choice.

Top 5 Price Testing Apps for Shopify Stores

Price testing on Shopify requires tools that can split traffic cleanly, track revenue impact, and help you read results with confidence. Below are five apps commonly used for pricing experiments.

1. GemX  - Smarter A/B Testing and Funnel Analytics

GemX is built specifically for experiment-led CRO on Shopify, with pricing experiments treated as a core use case, not a side feature. Instead of focusing only on conversion rate, GemX emphasizes revenue-first decision making, which is critical for price testing.

Best for

• Merchants who want to test prices using real conversion and revenue data

• Teams that care about revenue per visitor, not just clicks

• Shopify stores that want to run pricing tests without touching checkout code

Key strengths

• Tracks revenue per visitor, conversion rate, and AOV per price variant

• Clear experiment analytics with confidence indicators

• Designed to fit Shopify’s structure (themes, templates, product pages)

Why GemX works well for price testing

Pricing experiments often look “worse” on conversion rate but “better” on revenue. However, GemX makes it easy to evaluate price variants using revenue impact, reducing the risk of choosing the wrong winner.

The workflow encourages disciplined experimentation: hypothesis → test → read results → apply winner.

GemX is especially effective for merchants who want to validate pricing decisions before rolling them out storewide, making price optimization a controlled, low-risk process rather than a blind change.

2. Elevate A/B Testing Price Test

Elevate is a lightweight app focused specifically on price A/B testing, designed for quick setup and simple comparisons.

Best for

• Merchants running basic product price tests

• Stores that want fast execution with minimal configuration

Why merchants choose Elevate

• Simple price variant setup

• Easy traffic splitting

• Beginner-friendly interface

Limitation: Limited depth in analytics

3. Absolutely: A/B Testing Prices

Absolutely is a price testing app built for ease of use, allowing merchants to validate pricing assumptions without technical setup.

Best for

• Small Shopify stores

• Merchants testing prices for the first time

Why merchants choose Absolutely

• Straightforward price experiment setup

• Low learning curve

• Quick deployment

Limitation: Fewer advanced experiment controls, and limited reporting for deeper pricing analysis

4. Shoplift - Split & A/B Testing

Shoplift is a general split testing tool that supports pricing experiments alongside layout and content tests.

Best for

• Merchants running multiple experiment types

• Stores that want one tool for pricing and UX testing

Why merchants choose Shoplift

• Flexible split testing across elements

• Supports pricing, content, and layout tests

• Centralized experiment management

Limitation: Less specialized for revenue-based price decisions

5. Intelligems: A/B Testing

Intelligems is widely used by DTC brands to test pricing, shipping, and offers, with a strong emphasis on profit and margin impact.

Best for

• Brands testing price alongside shipping or bundling strategies

• Revenue- and margin-focused growth teams

Why merchants choose Intelligems

• Profit-focused reporting

• Supports pricing, shipping, and offer experiments

• Popular in data-driven DTC ecosystems

Limitation: More complex setup than basic price testing tools

How to Interpret Price Test Results the Right Way

Price tests don’t fail because of bad tools. They fail because results are misread. Use the checklist below to make the right call.

1. Don’t Call a Winner Too Early

Before picking a winning price, make sure:

• The test ran long enough (ideally 14–28 days)

• Both variants received comparable traffic

• Results are stable, not swinging day by day

If performance changes dramatically from one week to another, you’re likely seeing noise, not a real signal.

Pro tip: Remember this rule of thumb: If results don’t hold across multiple business cycles, don’t ship them.

2. Know Which Metric Actually Matters

When reading pricing experiments, use this priority order:

• Revenue per visitor (RPV): primary decision metric

• Conversion rate: supporting signal

• Average order value: context only

A price variant that converts less but generates higher RPV is often the correct winner. Picking based on conversion rate alone is the fastest way to underprice your product.

3. What to Do When Results Are Inconclusive

Not every price test produces a clear winner, that’s normal. If your test results are flat or unclear:

• Keep the current price

• Adjust the price gap (e.g., test $29 vs $35 instead of $29 vs $31)

• Run a follow-up test with a longer duration or fewer variants

An inconclusive test is still useful, which can tells you that price sensitivity may be lower than expected.

4. Sanity-check before Rolling out

Before applying the winning price storewide,

• Re-check results by traffic source

• Confirm revenue lift is not coming from one abnormal day

• Make sure no other changes ran during the test

Conclusion

Price testing on Shopify isn’t about guessing cheaper prices or copying competitors. It’s about understanding how customers actually respond to different price points, and choosing the option that maximizes revenue per visitor, not just conversions.

When done correctly, pricing experiments are one of the lowest-risk, highest-impact optimizations a Shopify store can run. Start small, test one variable at a time, and let real data guide your decisions.

If you want to run clean, revenue-first price tests without complex setup, GemX gives you the structure, metrics, and confidence needed to turn pricing decisions into proven growth.

Start testing prices the right way

GemX empowers Shopify merchants to test page variations, optimize funnels, and boost revenue lift.

Start Free Trial

FAQs about Price Testing

Can you A/B test product prices on Shopify?

Yes, but not natively. Shopify doesn’t support built-in price A/B testing, so merchants need third-party apps to split traffic and compare price variants accurately.

What metric matters most in price testing?

Revenue per visitor (RPV) is the most important metric. Conversion rate alone can be misleading because a higher price may convert less but still generate more revenue overall.

How long should a price test run?

Most price tests should run 14–28 days, depending on traffic volume. This helps results stabilize across weekdays, weekends, and normal buying cycles.

What’s the safest way to test prices on Shopify?

The safest approach is to run price tests on a traffic split, not storewide, and only roll out changes after results are statistically stable. Tools like GemX are built to support this workflow.

Realted Topics: 

A/B Testing

,

Shopify Insights